We use cookies
Our site relies on them (cookie policy)
Blog

Option Schemes: deciphering the documentation

We often get asked by founders about what documents an option scheme involves. This is all you need to know

Sam Simpson

Introduction

Setting up an option scheme can be an exciting moment, giving your team a real stake in what they're helping to build. But it can also be overwhelming, and that's not helped by the amount of paperwork that's involved.

This article assumes you've already decided to set up a scheme. If you're still weighing it up, we explain why EMI option schemes can be a founder and employee win-win in a separate article.

We'll start by looking at the documents we produce to set up your scheme and grant your first options. Then we'll walk you through the documents used for everything that follows, from granting more options to exercising them.

Contents:

  1. Authorising Your Scheme
  2. The Key Documents
  3. Supporting Documents
  4. Post Grant Formalities
  5. Other Scheme Events

Authorising Your Scheme

We have three documents that are used to authorise your scheme. By authorise, we mean: to ensure that your board and shareholders have formally agreed to it, and that you are covering your legal bases before you promise anyone any shares.

  • Board Minutes: The record of the board meeting that establishes the scheme and creates (or increases) your option pool. They also set out why the board considers the company qualifies to grant EMI options, including the limits on gross assets (£120 million) and employees (fewer than 500). It's worth reading these properly, as the founders sign them to confirm those statements.
  • Shareholder Resolutions: Your shareholders' authority for the directors to create the pool, grant options over it, and issue the resulting shares without applying pre-emption rights. These resolutions need to be signed by the holders of at least 75% of the voting shares in your company, within 28 days or they lapse. The authority to grant lasts for five years. The platform produces this document for you and asks your voting shareholders to sign. If you already have that authority in place, you can skip it.
  • Shareholder Consents: A short letter giving any consent required under your shareholders' agreement or articles for you to grant options up to the size of the pool. It's only relevant if you have investors with consent rights, and it needs signing by enough of them to meet your company's investor consent threshold. Again, you can skip it if you already have those consents.

The Key Documents

The following documents are the ones your team will read most closely, and that future investors will want to check during due diligence. The first sets the rules for the whole scheme, and the others set the terms for each individual.

  • Scheme Rules: The rulebook for every option you grant, covering who can take part, when options can be exercised, and what happens on a sale, an IPO or when someone leaves. You only need one set, as EMI and unapproved options both sit under the same rules, and you can grant options under them for ten years. It's important to note that if the rules and an option agreement ever conflict, the option agreement wins.
  • EMI Option Agreement: The contract between the company and an eligible employee, with one for each grant. It sets out the number of shares, the option price and how the options vest, and the employee declares that they work at least 25 hours a week or, if less, 75% of their working time. Both parties sign it. Each employee can hold EMI options over shares worth up to £250,000, and the company up to £6 million in total, valued at the date of grant.
  • Unapproved Option Agreement: Almost the same contract, for advisors, contractors and anyone else who doesn't qualify for EMI. There's no working time declaration and no EMI tax treatment, but it doesn't need an HMRC valuation either. We cover how the two compare in a separate article.
  • Vesting Schedule: Not a separate document, but a schedule to each option agreement setting out when the options can be exercised. It can be based on a specific date, regular time periods (with or without a cliff), a condition being met, or an exit, and you can choose for options to vest in full on an exit. You can also decide that options can only be exercised on an exit, even once they've vested.

Supporting Documents

These documents support the price of your EMI options, by agreeing a share valuation with HMRC. You'll need one in place before you grant EMI options on FounderCatalyst, but unapproved options don't need them. If you already have a valuation agreed with HMRC, you can skip this step:

  • EMI Valuation Letter: Our letter to HMRC's Shares and Assets Valuation team, giving the background to your company and justifying the proposed valuation. It proposes both an actual market value and an unrestricted market value per share (in short, the value of a share with and without any restrictions attached).
  • VAL231: HMRC's form for requesting an EMI valuation. We prepare it for you to send to HMRC, along with the letter, your accounts and your articles and any other supporting documents required.

Once HMRC agree, the valuation is valid for 90 days from the date of the agreement. Any EMI options you grant after that will need a new valuation.

Post Grant Formalities

Don't forget, there are also formalities your company needs to undertake itself. We add the key dates to your calendar, and our guide to HMRC registration and reporting walks you through the HMRC steps.

Granting More Options

You've already got a full set of documentation, and the board authorised any director to sign option agreements when it approved the scheme. So, as long as there's room in your option pool, the only document to be used for each grant is:

  • EMI or Unapproved Option Agreement: The same as mentioned previously, with its own vesting schedule. We invite the option holder to the platform, where they add their details and sign.

For EMI options, you'll also need a valuation agreed within the last 90 days. If yours has expired, that means a new valuation submission.

Exercising Options

This is when an option holder turns their vested options into shares, by paying the option price. It uses three documents:

  • Exercise Notice: Signed by the option holder, this states how many shares they're acquiring and confirms how they'll pay the exercise price and any tax. It also binds them to your shareholders' agreement.
  • Board Minutes: Signed by the founders, these confirm that the notice is valid and authorise the issue of the shares.
  • Share Certificate: Issued to the option holder once the board minutes are signed.

We then add a reminder to your calendar to file form SH01 at Companies House within 30 days. Any exercise of EMI options also goes on your end of year return.

Leavers

There's no new document when someone leaves, but there is a decision to make. Under the scheme rules, a leaver's options lapse immediately unless their option agreement says otherwise or the directors decide otherwise. Someone normally becomes a leaver on the date notice is given, rather than on their last day, although the directors can choose a later date.

For example, someone might leave holding 10,000 options, of which 4,000 have vested. You might decide that they keep those 4,000, in which case the other 6,000 lapse and go back into your pool. You record this on the platform, and any lapse of EMI options then flows into your end of year return.


At FounderCatalyst, we help founders make their UK startups investor-ready, close funding rounds, and motivate their teams. We handle SEIS and EIS advance assurance, fundraising legal paperwork, data rooms, cap table management, and set up EMI and unapproved share option schemes. Book a call with an expert to learn more.

Was this helpful?

Back to all articles

Partnered with people that push you further

Digital Catapult logoAngel Investors Bristol logoEnvestors logoFemale Founders Rise logoAntler logoFuel Ventures logoSFC Capital logoRepublic Europe logoInnovate UK logoJumpstart logoFocused for Business logoSyndicateRoom logoAngel Groups logoFundMyPitch logoSwoop Funding logoColorintech logoThe Startup Foundry logoshipshape.vc logoAscension logoCrowdcube logoSETsquared Partnership logo